Subsidiary protection in Italy
Reviewed: 2026-09-22
Determine whether a person who does not qualify as a refugee may qualify for subsidiary protection in Italy, identify the serious-harm limb and evidence required, and model the individual-risk analysis.
Quick decision point
This procedure covers serious-harm analysis (death penalty/execution; torture/inhuman treatment; serious individual threat from indiscriminate violence in armed conflict) when refugee status is not established.
Previous legal state: where a Convention persecution claim is plausible, assess Refugee status in Italy first.
Refugee status is assessed first
Under the current EU procedure, the authority determines whether the applicant qualifies as a refugee and, if not, whether subsidiary protection applies. Do not present subsidiary protection as a free-standing shortcut around a plausible Convention refugee claim.
Three serious-harm limbs
Subsidiary protection focuses on a real risk of serious harm: death penalty or execution; torture or inhuman/degrading treatment or punishment; or a serious and individual threat to a civilian’s life or person by reason of indiscriminate violence in international or internal armed conflict. Identify the limb before gathering evidence because each requires a different factual architecture.
Individual circumstances remain material
EUAA’s 2026 guidance stresses that the authority must examine all relevant factors relating both to the applicant’s individual position/personal circumstances and the general situation before identifying the serious-harm type. Country reports alone do not automatically prove the individual case.
Article 15(c)-type conflict analysis
For indiscriminate-violence cases, do not use a fixed casualty ratio as a legal threshold. In C-901/19 CF and DN, the CJEU held that Article 15(c) precludes a rule conditioning protection on a fixed casualty threshold and requires a comprehensive appraisal of all circumstances of the individual case, especially the country-of-origin situation. Current EUAA guidance likewise uses an individualised, sliding-scale analysis. Document the applicant’s home area, conflict intensity, civilian impact, actual destination on return, mobility and personal circumstances that increase exposure.
Protection and internal relocation
As with refugee analysis, effective protection and a legally available internal-protection alternative can defeat the need for international protection. Test whether the proposed location is actually safe, accessible and reasonable for this person, considering age, health, family, documentation, gender and livelihood realities.
Procedure, exclusion and next action
The Territorial Commission examines the protection claim. Exclusion grounds must be tested separately from the serious-harm merits. A negative decision requires immediate review of the applicable judicial-remedy route and deadline. If subsidiary protection is recognised, Italy’s official Integration Portal states that the residence permit is issued for five years and is renewable subject to the applicable status rules.
Failure modes
Typical errors are jumping straight to conflict statistics without identifying the serious-harm limb, treating any instability as Article 15(c)-level indiscriminate violence, ignoring individual vulnerability, failing to test internal protection, or using subsidiary protection where a Convention nexus actually supports refugee status.
Serious-harm limb matrix
| Limb | Core question | Evidence focus |
|---|---|---|
| Death penalty/execution | Is there a real risk of capital punishment/execution on return? | Charges, sentence/exposure, law and enforcement practice. |
| Torture / inhuman or degrading treatment | Is there a real risk of prohibited treatment? | Personal profile, detention/treatment history, actor capability and COI. |
| Armed-conflict indiscriminate violence | Is the applicant a civilian facing a serious individual threat by reason of indiscriminate violence? | Home area, conflict intensity, civilian harm, personal risk factors and mobility. |
Individual-risk overlay
| Factor | Why it changes analysis |
|---|---|
| Home area / route of return | Risk is geographically specific. |
| Age, disability, health | Can increase exposure and reduce relocation feasibility. |
| Gender / family status | Can alter exposure and access to protection. |
| Occupation / ethnicity / prior targeting | May increase personal risk above baseline violence. |
| Ability to relocate safely and lawfully | Can affect internal-protection analysis. |
Three case tests
- Applicant faces death penalty on return but no refugee nexus. Main risk: correct serious-harm limb and individual real risk. Evidence: sentence/law/enforcement COI. Next action: analyse Article 15(a)-type harm after refugee-first determination.
- Civilian returns to conflict area with high violence but no special profile. Main risk: using a fixed casualty cutoff. Evidence: current area-specific conflict/civilian data and return destination. Next action: comprehensive C-901/19 appraisal.
- Applicant has vulnerability increasing exposure in a moderately violent area. Main risk: ignoring personal circumstances in Article 15(c) analysis. Evidence: medical/vulnerability facts + area COI. Next action: apply individualised sliding-scale analysis and test internal protection.
Sources used for material rules
- EUR-Lex — Regulation (EU) 2024/1347 (Qualification Regulation) — Substantive subsidiary-protection definition and serious-harm criteria. (Primary; checked 2026-09-22)
- EUR-Lex — Corrigendum to Regulation (EU) 2024/1347 — Correct current application date of the Qualification Regulation. (Primary; checked 2026-09-22)
- EUR-Lex — Regulation (EU) 2024/1348 — Procedural sequence: determine refugee status first and, if not, subsidiary protection; transition from 12 June 2026. (Primary; checked 2026-09-22)
- CJEU — C-901/19 CF and DN — Article 15(c): no fixed casualty threshold; comprehensive appraisal of all circumstances required. (Primary; checked 2026-09-22)
- Italian Integration Portal — Rights recognised to beneficiaries of international protection — Official Italian government portal: five-year residence permit and core rights for beneficiaries of international protection. (Primary; checked 2026-09-22)
- EUAA — Subsidiary protection, Country Guidance: Explained (February 2026) — Current practical explanation of refugee-first sequence, serious harm and individual circumstances. (External corpus; checked 2026-09-22)
- EUAA — Serious and individual threat (February 2026) — Current sliding-scale analysis for Article 15(c)-type risk. (External corpus; checked 2026-09-22)
- UNHCR Italy — International protection and special protection — User-facing rights/status baseline in Italy. (External corpus; checked 2026-09-22)